Rob Bell…heretic or hero ?

Rob Bell, the charismatic founder of the Mars Hill Bible Church in Grand Rapids, MI. Known as an innovative speaker, pastor, teacher, lecturer and author. Deemed by some to be a hero, and to others a heretic. Pastor Bell’s book, “Love Wins” is in the middle of all out debate online, in print, on tv and among Christian theologians on the nature of Hell…he is as controversial as radioactive baby food. Is he a Heretic ? Or is he a Hero?

The Question I believe is actually deeper than that… instead of focusing on the media fire storm around the book, what about the actual discussion on the ideas in the book? For me, one detail has emerged far and above the rest, and that does not involve a discussion on Hell, but what about our understanding of “Heaven”?

Is it possible that we have been over-simplifying and under-emphasising the Hope of the gospel ?

After reading the book… (which to discuss intelligently is a MUST) I believe you will find yourself agreeing with and dis-agreeing with Mr. Bell on several issues. His avoidance of the significant issue of what Judgement is, or could be or will be for souls after death is notable in the book. So for now, the confidence to label the man a HERETIC is off the table for me.

As far as calling him a HERO… I’m not willing to go that far…yet. Jury is still out. For now, I’ll say no. (See Francis Chan’s Video Commentary on this… His comments are precisely what I felt but couldn’t articulate after reading Rob’s book… )

But what about Heaven ?

That is the most fascinating question, the critical “take away” reminder that Rob Bell brings to us from his book. As Christians in a culture of media and marketing and canned infomercial styled faith, we may be guilty of missing the point.  What if the gospel wasn’t just a “get out of jail” card for our soul after death, but a solution for life, practical and available in the “here and now” ? What if Eternal life, was describing what life was meant to be like, and is now possible for those who embrace Jesus as the savior he claimed to be?

What if the whole perspective on our lives was meant to be lived with the reality that everything old was made new, and that everything broken was to be made whole and that every loss redeemed? That the power of the cross was sufficient to re-birth our lives as they were meant to be lived. A fresh start, a radical transformation. Then, the punishment for those who reject that gospel of new life would have to be… old life. Dying… Hopelessness, brokeness, despair… Hell.

That’s fascinating, even likely. But not the point.

Does our understanding of the bible and Jesus then rule out the existence of Hell ? I do not belive so. Rob seems to imply he might go there… ?Not my concern, its debatable, unknowable and brilliant faithful Christian minds for over a thousand years have raised the same question with similar results.

In the end, for me its to some degree irrelevant, my concern is living my life now. I believe that Rob is right in this portion of his reasoning… God has provided us all with the option to “Choose” to live from a “New” source of life that is available only in a re-united relationship with God (Jesus). To choose not to do that is our freedom… and our responsibility. To reject that life leads to Hell.

To accept that leads to salvation… Such a “New” saved life should explode with vibrant and relentless love, hope and peace. That life would influence everyone around it, and that witness would provide to the poor, the dying and the oppressed of the tangible evidence that there is a savior. It would reek of Jesus and it would be impossible to deny that a life in Christ was literally like living as though we were in heaven now.

What I see instead for most of us professing Christians… is something closer to simple survival.

Rob Bell in his controversy, I believe is providing us all with a very powerful platform for further study… forget the issue of whether Hell is a literal or figurative concept. What about “Heaven”? Have you actually considered that the life Jesus promised for us all, is more than a harp and some blue sky… it might be right in front of you now, waiting for you to discover, today ?

In the end, you need to read the book and you need to read it with an open bible. Search the scriptures, find out if what you think you believe is what it really says. You might be surprised at what you find… I was.

Bit of departure from our usual parenting fare today, but I thought it was worth the time, and curious as to your own observations on this controversial subject.

Peace out,


3 thoughts on “Rob Bell…heretic or hero ?

  1. Kimberly Wax Rund
    Brad, thanks for posting this. I went to a neighbor’s Bible study a few years back and before each study, we watched one of his 15 minute videos. They were powerful films. However, one or two of them bothered me ( I remember the one with…See More

    Thursday at 3:38pm · Like.

    Leslie Marie I struggle with this book. I have read it in the last two weeks. I am cautious for a few reasons. I have his other books and have enjoyed those. I will give him one thing he knows how to market the book.
    Thursday at 4:07pm · Like.

    Kimberly Wax Rund Can you tell me why you struggled with it, Leslie?
    Thursday at 9:11pm · Like.

    Brad Mathias
    ‎Kimberly Wax Rund and Leslie Marie, the book is a tough one. It on one hand is an amazing overview of the heart of God for redemption and on the other it delves into the concept that because of God’s heart… there must be a way to sideste…See More

    Yesterday at 7:54am · Like.

    Keith Mohr I have not read the book yet, but I understand where Rob is coming from. However, God does not send anyone to hell. We separate ourselves from God, and when we were separated, we are in hell. Just like heaven is from beginning to end, so is hell. At least that’s what I think.. could be prophetic, could be pathetic:)
    Yesterday at 10:45am · Like.

    Leslie Marie
    Yes, Brad Mathias that is exactly where I am with this book. I agree with Keith too. I agree that is not God who sends us to Hell but our choices. In the book, [I am reading it on a Kindle so I can’t tell the page #], when he is giving t…See More

    22 hours ago · Like.

    Leslie Marie Thanks for asking Brad…I feel safe sorting out my feelings on this here…
    22 hours ago · Like.

    Keith Mohr we are responsible.. if we sow hell here on earth, we will reap hell after we depart this earth. God does not torment us, we do it to ourselves.
    22 hours ago · Like · 1 person.

    Leslie Marie
    What do you think of this… The content of Love Wins/Rob Bell’s teaching would seem to be exactly what Paul was warning Timothy of “For the time will come when men will not put up with sound doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, t…See More

    22 hours ago · Like.

    Brad Mathias
    Leslie, I personally disagree with Mr Bell’s conclusion on Hell. But appreciate his criticsm of the evangelical canned gospel. There is judgement, there will be justice & consequences to man’s actions on earth. It’s all just an opinion on the details after death. No one can know for sure…but the sacrifice & horrific death of Jesus certainly points to severe consequences to sin. CS Lewis really explores this well in his classic the “screwtape letters”.

    4 hours ago · Like · 1 person.

    Keith Mohr we do not have to wait for death to realize the consequences of sin..
    3 hours ago · Like.

    Leslie Marie double LIKE Keith..
    3 hours ago · Like.

    Keith Mohr nor do we need to wait for death to experience heaven.
    3 hours ago · Like.

    Brad Mathias Ahh.. Yes Keith. That would be “THE” point i believe of Mr. Bell’s book. 🙂



    • Thanks for your comment CHINYERE; my position on that is as noted in my blog.. “Does our understanding of the bible and Jesus then rule out the existence of Hell ? I do not belive so.” I agree with you. But that is not the point. The point is… does you’re life have any evidence of “Heaven” in it ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s